Nominations clarifications part 2

[dhampyresa]

If any nominations have been approved or rejected by mistake, please tell me. Likewise if there are any mistakes in the tagset.

Clarifications needed:

• In "Brat'ya Karamazovy | Brothers Karamazov - Fyodor Dostoyevsky" is "Lizaveta" Lizaveta Ivanovna or another character of the same given name?


• "The Evil Within (Video Game)" has over 500 works that are complete, in English and over 1k words. Please provide evidence that it is eligible.


• In "Black Panther (2018)" who is "N'Yami"? I could not find any character with that name in the movie.


• In "Black Panther (2018)" does "Steve" appear in this movie?


• In "Gundam SEED Astray", ao3 suggests "Rondo Gina Sahaku" as the canonical spelling of "Rondo Ghina Sahaku". Is this correct?


• In "Justice League (2017)", does "Relationship: Barry Allen/The rest of the league" mean "Relationship: Barry Allen/The rest of the Justice League" or something else?


• In "Love & Friendship (2016)", ao3 suggest "Susan Vernon" as the canonical for "Lady Susan Vernon". Is this correct?


• In "Make It or Break It", ao3 suggest "Sasha Beloff" as the canonical for "Sasha Belov". Is this correct?


• In "The Duelist (2016)", the nomination "Prince Tuchkov/Pyotr Petrovich Yakovlev |" needs to be edited.


• In "Екатерина | Catherine (TV 2014)", ao3 suggests "Pyotr III Fyodorovich | Peter III of Russia" as the canonical for "Pyotr Fyodorovich | Peter III of Russia". Is this correct?


• Ao3 suggests "Robotech" as the canonical for "Robotech (Titan Comics)". Is this correct?

Comments

Black Panther

[(Anonymous)]

Sorry, I googled wrong, the name of T'Challa's mother is Ramonda, not N'Yami.

Steve was in Wakanda when Bucky got frozen, we don't know exactly when he left or when he comes back (or if he drops in sometimes) but that scene didn't appear in the Black Panther movie but in Civil War.

Re: Black Panther

[dhampyresa]

Should I edit the nominations to "relationship: Erik & Okoye & Nakia & Shuri & Ramonda & T'Challa & M'Baku" and "relationship: Ramonda & T'Challa & Shuri", then?

Only characters actually present within the movie are eligible.

Re: Black Panther

[(Anonymous)]

Fair enough. And yes please.

Re: Black Panther

[(Anonymous)]

Actually went and corrected them myself to save you the bother :)

Re: Black Panther

[dhampyresa]

Thank you.

[muccamukk]

I didn't nominate Love & Friendship, but that is correct.

[jedibuttercup]

I did, and it probably is. I was a bit confused about whether I should include the title because when I looked under existing child tags for Love & Friendship, I saw "Lord Manwaring" and "Sir James Martin" - but I think generally they probably do take the titles off?

[dhampyresa]

Thank you. I'll approve it as Susan Vernon, then.

[dhampyresa]

Thank you.

[cookiegirl]

Sasha Belov is usually spelt Belov I think, (http://make-it-or-break-it.wikia.com/wiki/Sasha_Belov) but yeah it looks like the tag on ao3 is Beloff, so may as well use that (not sure how the tagging process goes exactly)! Weirdly, the relationship tag ao3 have is Sasha Belov/Payson Keeler. It's definitely the same character though. I think they may be the Romanian and English/US variations on the name.

[dhampyresa]

I'll keep it as Belov, then, to be consistent with the relationships. Tags in tagsets have no bearing on fic tags, though, fyi.

Thank you.

[taichara]

Ao3 suggests "Robotech" as the canonical for "Robotech (Titan Comics)". Is this correct?

This is not correct -- the ongoing Titan version is a new reboot and began sharply diverging from the original in plot and characterization within the first few issues. (Synning them is much like synning the Marvel movies to the Marvel comics continuity.)

[dhampyresa]

I thought it was something like this. I'll approve the fandom as "Robotech (Titan Comics)", then. Thank you.

[kalloway]

In "Gundam SEED Astray", ao3 suggests "Rondo Gina Sahaku" as the canonical spelling of "Rondo Ghina Sahaku". Is this correct?

This is a little fussy, because the English localization done more than a decade ago used Ghina, to emphasize that it's a hard-G, and I could ramble for far too long about name variations in the series...

But the short answer is that both versions have been used so whichever is fine.

[dhampyresa]

Thank you.

I'll go with the ao3 canonical, then.

I bungled a tag's spelling in AO3, sorry

[(Anonymous)]

Sorry if this is inappropriate here, but I don't think I can contact mods on AO3. I am wavewright62 over there, and in my tagset for 'Far to the North,' I misspelled "Temmrien" as 'Tammrien.' Is there any way this can be fixed? I'd hate for any fic to have the wrong tag. I'd appreciate any advice you can forward, thank you.

Re: I bungled a tag's spelling in AO3, sorry

[morbane]

Sure, this is a good place to bring that up. We'll correct it - thanks! (ETA - Now fixed.)

dhampyresa also lists "nightonficmountainmod@gmail.com" as a possible contact point (in the profile of this dw comm) if you'd prefer to use email for any further comments or queries.

[biffelderberry]

"In "Justice League (2017)", does "Relationship: Barry Allen/The rest of the league" mean "Relationship: Barry Allen/The rest of the Justice League" or something else?"

Sorry yes, I meant "Relationship: Barry Allen/The Rest of the Justice League."

[dhampyresa]

Tahnk you. I've approved the clarified version.

[(Anonymous)]

Sorry for the off-topic comment, but when nominations do close exactly?

[(Anonymous)]

+1

I've also been wondering this.

[dhampyresa]

Nominations will close at 2200 UTC.

[alley_skywalker]

For Catherine 2014 - yes that's the right canonical. Do I need to edit it on my end, or will you guys take care of that?

I saw The Duelist nom was approved. Does anything further need to be done for it?

[morbane]

Thanks. We can approve the Catherine 2014 nomination.

Should be OK! I ended up approving it based on Yuletide's tag set.